Difference between fatah and hamas difference between. Hamass fatah and the nostate solution gatestone institute. Hamas accepts egyptian proposal to end dispute with fatah egypt has exerted heavy pressure on hamas and fatah to end the enmity between them. Since hamass election victory, particularly sharp infighting has occurred between hamas and fatah. Pdf the continues failure of the mediation and reconciliation. Hamas, which has long been trying unsuccessfully to mobilize arab and international public opinion to events in the gaza strip, was accorded worldwide coverage of its version of events a popular, nonviolent palestinian protest that israel turned into a bloodbath with its unbridled, indiscriminate live fire at participants television channels around the world aired the photos and.
Unity deal offers hope for palestinians and a respite for. This report provides an overview of the new political realities in the west bank and gaza after the election, the challenges fatah and hamas face. As fallout from the hamas takeover of the gaza strip enters its second week, diane rehm welcomes shibley telhami and david makovsky, senior fellow and director of. Fatah participated in the anniversary of the establishment of hamas on december 8, 2012. The joint fatahhamas statement in cairo this week announcing an impending agreement between. Translation of leaked hamasfatah agreement the times of. The main reason is a drastic decline in support for fatah in jerusalem, so that it is the islamic movements such as hamas and the international hizb uttahrir movement, which advocates a caliphate.
Rival palestinian groups hamas, fatah reach deal over control of gaza. And fatahs shaath, also speaking in gaza, said preparations were underway to release dozens of hamas prisoners being held in the west bank. By ramzy baroud egypts enthusiasm to arbitrate between feuding palestinian factions, hamas and fatah, is not the outcome of a sudden awakening of conscience. In fact, since the civil war that saw hamas oust the fatahdominated palestinian authority pa from gaza in 2007, the two sides have announced at. The twoway if the egyptianbrokered deal succeeds, the palestinian territories of. The fatahhamas reconciliation agreement of october 2017. Disagreements emerge between hamas and fatah middle east. Hamas, fatah reach palestinian unity deal at cairo talks. Hamas and islamic jihad clash over media jihad the. Palestinian rivals fatah, hamas sign reconciliation accord. Ive warned time and again that hamas and fatah the u. Hamas in combat the washington institute for near east. Hamas won a major victory, taking 74 of the 2 seats, in an election deemed fair and honest by international observers. Chronology of conflict history between fatah, hamas.
Both fatah and hamas are preparing for major demonstrations, hoping to bring attention to decades of oppressive israeli rule. It would make more sense to merge history of fatahhamas tensions into this article, as palestinian factional violence is a more general topic, and if any other palestinian factions start fighting they can be included in this article. But the events are also likely to underscore how much ground they have lost to israel and how the pressure for new thinking is. Executive force was merged with the official police force. Bush, america spent billions training and arming the p. But the events are also likely to underscore how much ground they have lost to israel and how the pressure for new thinking is coming from the ground up, not from the leadership.
Hamasfatah conflict also known as the palestinian civil war and as the wakseh arabic for selfinflicted ruin or humiliation. Hamas and fatah would return to cairo in early december to assess implementation of the agreement, the official said. The new hamas policy document is not, as it is claimed to be, the equivalent of the fatah transformation in 1988. Heads of fatah and hamas delegations, azzam alahmad left and saleh alaruri right after signing a reconciliation deal in cairo, october 12, 2017. Palestinian factions, fatah and hamas, move toward. Fatah welcomes hamas pledge to try ending palestinian split. The foreign policy of the eu in the palestinian territory. Even if there are still major obstacles to merging the two security apparatuses, establishing a unity government, restoring the democratic process. I t h as been active since 2008 but its activities are focused. To this end, hamas and islamic jihad negotiated a preliminary deal to merge their military wings in late 2003, reportedly agreed upon but in the end never implemented by hamas leader khalid mishal and islamic jihad leader ramadan shallah at a meeting of the groups leadership in beirut.
The conflict between hamas and fatah began in january 2006 and has continued to greater and lesser extents until today as of 2015, though internecine killings ended in 2009. Yassin led widespread religious and social activity, but only at the outbreak of the first intifada did he decide that the movement should take part in the military. Palestinian factions need to reinvent themselves and find successful strategies to give the public hope, analysts say. Rival palestinian factions hamas and fatah signed a reconciliation deal on thursday after hamas agreed to hand over administrative control of gaza, including the key rafah border crossing, a. Following the battle of gaza in june of 2007, elected hamas officials were ousted from their positions in the palestinian national authority government in the west bank and replaced by rival fatah members and independents in an action that many.
Fatah harakat altahrir alfilastiniyya the palestinian. Pdf why the mediation process between the palestinian rivals. Only when hamas staged a coup and mahmoud abbas set up a separate governing entity for the west bank did we resume aid. Hamas and fatahs role in the jerusalem disturbances.
Rival palestinian factions hamas and fatah reach unity. Hamas accuses fatah of trying to foil truce with israel. Fatah and hamas sign a new reconciliation agreement in october. Comparisons between hamas and groups that blend political islam with. The islamist principles of one of its founders, sheik ahmed yassin, differed starkly from. Hamas and fatah disagree on a lot, from peace negotiations to political ideology. On thursday, the two movements announced they had reached a deal to end a decadelong rift that brought them. Translation of leaked hamasfatah agreement full text of the accord signed last week contains six clauses agreed upon by the rival factions. This period of quiet, however, does not signal the end of hamass struggle. Our vision is to combine them without focusing exclusively on either. Our islamic palestinian terrorists unite with theirs. Plo would invariably mean joining in a broad partnership with the pa, islamic. They also accused fatah of reneging on an earlier promise to release some 500 hamas members from pa prisons in advance of the summit.
According to hamas officials, the eleventhhour decision came in answer to fatahs actions in the west bank, where the pa has continued to wage a sweeping campaign of arrest against resistance activists. The struggle for palestine, jonathan schanzer joins the ranks of the most insightful observers the dynamics of the arabisraeli conflict by focusing his attention at the struggle that may have the greatest impact on the future disposition of the palestinian independence movement the intrapalestinian contest between. On june 14, hamas defeated fatah in gaza and took complete control of the territory, from which israel unilaterally withdrew in august 2005. They begin to implement the agreement on november 1, as hamas gives control of gaza border. Its rival, the oncedominant fatah party, criticized for ineffectiveness. Agreement between fatah and hamas cairo, 3 may 2011 under the auspices of egypt, delegations from the fatah and hamas movements met in cairo on april 27, 2011 to discuss the issues concerning ending the political division and the achievement of national unity. Hamas and fatah sign deal over control of gaza strip this article is more than 2 years old egyptianbrokered talks between rival palestinian factions are latest attempt to end decadelong. Cairo has, in fact, played a destructive role in manipulating palestinian division to its favor, while keeping the rafah border crossing under lock and key. Hamas, fatah battle over palestinian public opinion. After the end of the cold war 1991, politics have been defined by the victory of democracy, which has been seen as the panacea for failed states. Khaled desoukiafp palestinian factions have agreed to hold general elections by the end of 2018 after talks in cairo spearheaded by rivals hamas and fatah, a joint statement by all the groups. Abbas loses control of gaza and responds by sacking haniya, who ignores the dismissal.
The contested road to statehood analyses the palestinian. Hamas and fatah sign deal over control of gaza strip. Background and issues for congress congressional research service 1 introduction. In gaza, hamas has taken the shambles of palestinian authority institu tions and worked to. Meeting in cairo for new round of reconciliation talks, fatah and hamas disagree on key issues. Hamas, the arabic word for zeal, is the acronym of alharakat almuqawwama alislamiyyathe islamic resistance movement. The divisions between the two main palestinian political factions, fatah and hamas, are not religious as nearly all palestinian muslims are from the sunni branch of islam. After months of unrest and internal instability, the two parties found an agreement and fatah joined the unity government as junior partner while hamas became the senior partner in march 2007. Thus, the viability of a twostate solution rested on an israeli acknowledgement of the islamist movement, hamas, and on fatahs ceding power to it. Fighting between fatah and hamas gunmen in gaza escalates into a systematic and bloody assault by hamas on fatah headquarters throughout the strip of fatahdominated security forces answering to abbas.
On top of the issues were some reservations related to the palestinian national. Between those fatah who favor a secular model of governance and those hamas who call for a society governed more by islamic norms. Palestinian reconciliation and the potential of transitional justice. Last week, hamas spokesman taher alnunu said the group would grant amnesty to some 30 fatahaffiliated political prisoners held after the group took over the gaza strip in 2007. The bloody hamasfatah power struggle that threatens to.
Abbas appoints fayyad, an independent and internationally respected economist, to head. While hamas has waged a violent campaign aimed at israel and at its own palestinian rivals, primarily fatah, it is currently restraining its military activity and that of other palestinian groups in the gaza strip. Fatah also allowed hamas to hold festivals in the west bank. Fatah and hamas sign a reconcilliation agreement in april and form a unity government, on june 2 abbas swears in the new government. Under terms of the deal, hamas and the palestinian authority will form a joint police force of at least 5,000 officers, and merge their ministries. The split began when hamas won palestinian elections in 2006, leading to bloody gun battles on the streets of gaza when fatah did not cede power. The third man had been overheard on the street criticizing hamas. Several weeks after the signing of the october 12, 2017 reconciliation agreement between fatah and hamas, the euphoria that had initially been felt on the palestinian street, and even more so in political circles, seems to be waning, and there are increasing doubts as to the possibility of reaching an understanding between the sides. Regional actors and the fatahhamas unity deal european.
Issues for congress hamas,1 or the islamic resistance movement, is a palestinian islamist military and sociopolitical movement that grew out of the muslim brotherhood, a sunni religious and political organization. As early as october 2000, hamas leader mahmoud zahar announced that hamas and islamic jihad leaders were meeting with fatah and palestinian authority officials at least once daily. How israel should respond to the fatahhamas merger. Some members of hamas are open to an israeli state within the pre. On january 9, 20, abbas held talks with khaled mashaal, head of the hamas political bureau, in cairo, and agreed to implement the palestinian reconciliation agreement, only for it not to be. Hamas joining the pna, reduce violence, and be part of the peace process, but. The issues dividing hamas and fatah also include muhammad dahlan, a former fatah security chief in gaza, who has been in exile in the united arab emirates since a. Egypt was instrumental in orchestrating the fatahhamas reconciliation, hosting. Hamas and fatah are the two most dominant parties in the palestinian political scene. The group was established by the palestinian branch of the muslim broth.
114 946 1206 1000 197 429 1240 1421 573 161 69 1548 352 281 1318 675 1087 663 1204 263 148 1521 1326 107 618 124 997 210 503 109 863 1037 1462 545 751 894 220 87 1035 197 1066 705 797 1147 1414 855